Munich personal repec archive herzbergs motivationhygiene theory and job satisfaction in the malaysian retail sector. The need hierarchy was later adapted to the work context from top to bottom. Differences and similarities between maslow en herzberg. Maslow s hierarchy of needs is a theory in psychology anticipated by abraham maslow in his 1943 paper a theory of human motivation. Similarities and dissimilarities between maslows theory and herzbergs theory of motivation. This will result in improving organizational performance.
Understanding herzbergs motivation theory understanding what motivates people in all walks of life is basic to all who aspire to management. Jan 20, 2014 the dual structure theory herzberg proposed the motivationhygiene theory, also known as the the dual structure theory or two factor theory 1959 of job satisfaction. The motivation process behind the management team of xxxx consists of the respected theories of abraham maslow and fredrick herzberg. Herzberg and maslows motivational theories asssignment essay. It is applicable to rich and developed countries where money is less important motivating factor.
Herzbergs theory of motivation and maslows hierarchy of needs joseph e gawel the catholic university of america among various behavioral theories long generally believed and embraced by american business are those of frederick herzberg and abraham maslow. Herzbergs twofactor theory explains why the best and highly paid members leave your project. The theory proposes that most factors which contribute to job. Gawel among various behavioral theories long generally believed and embraced by american business are those of frederick herzberg and abraham maslow. These attempt to explain the factors that motivate individuals through identifying and satisfying their individual needs, desires and the aims pursued to satisfy these desires. Abstract motivational factors play an important role in increasing employee job satisfaction. Compare and contrast maslows hierarchy of needs with herzbergs twofactor theory of motivation motivation is an intangible human asset which acts as a driver that pushes humans to be willing to perform certain actions. Application of the maslows hierarchy of need theory.
Herzbergs theory is an extension of maslows theory of motivation. Ed421486 19970700 herzbergs theory of motivation and. Content theories of motivation herzbergs motivation theory is one of the content theories of motivation. Pdf application of frederick herzbergs twofactor theory. Herzbergs theory of motivation and maslows hierarchy of needs joseph e. Herzbergs framework is compatible with maslows hierarchy of needs. In fact, from a practical perspective, the influence of herzbergs motivation theory can be seen at every organizational level as well as within every department. Herzbergs motivationhygiene theory and job satisfaction in. And like with maslows theory of needs, i will explain herzbergs dual factor theory from the perspective of the practical application you dont have to be a physiologist to see and act on the motivation of your team.
According to his theory, people are influenced by two sets of factors. In contrast, herzberg s theory on motivation reveals that there are a number of variables existing at the workplace that results in job satisfaction or dissatisfaction. Their findings, however, show a general alignment with herzbergs two factor theory of motivation. Difference between maslow and herzbergs theory of motivation. It is on the other hand applicable to rich and developed countries where money is less important motivating factor. In 1959, frederick herzberg, a behavioural scientist proposed a twofactor theory or the motivatorhygiene theory. Herzbergs motivationhygiene theory and job satisfaction. Schools of thought in relation to motivation refer to the theories developed by different psychologists to explain motivation in dept. The twofactor theory also known as herzbergs motivationhygiene theory and dualfactor theory states that there are certain factors in the workplace that cause job satisfaction, while a separate set of factors cause dissatisfaction. Herzbergs twofactor theory of motivation applied to the motivational techniques within financial institutions abstract throughout time, many have attempted to develop detailed theories and studies of motivation, satisfaction, and selfawareness. Generating performance from minimum wage employees. Similarities between all three all are theories of motivation outlines how to best understand and motivate employees. One of the best known of all the writers on motivation is herzberg. Herzbergs two factor theory sometimes dual factor theory or herzberg motivation theory is one of the motivation theories and it suitably complements, for example, maslows pyramid.
This theory of motivation is known as a two factor content. Accordingly, herzbergs twofactor theory posits that a good leader would give motivation to the members of staff in the organisation so that they would do their job well yusoff et al. Herzbergs twofactor theory, mcclellands need theory, and maslows hierarchy of needs all talk about higherlevel psychological needs such as achievement, recognition, responsibility, and advancement. Motivationmaslows hierarchy of needs and herzberg two. Motivation studies found that employees are not motivated solely by money and employee behaviour is linked to their attitudes dickson, 1973. Frederick herzbergs theory of motivation identifies two sets of factors that cause an employee to experience job satisfaction or dissatisfaction. Herzberg theory of motivation herzberg s twofactor theory of motivation motivational theories and application to a highly creative and complex technology workforce behaviors of motivational theories herzberg s two factor theory v s job characteristics model motivation theories and sun 2 shade company maslow s and herzberg s theories theories. There is a great similarity between maslow and herzberg models as both stresses on different needs of individuals. Others also commented that his theory could not be of practical use to managers, as it merely classified the needs that everyone has. Maslow s theory is a general theory on motivation which expresses that the urge to satisfy needs is the principle variable in motivation. Using maslow s hierarchy of needs and herzberg s motivation hygiene supposition, this company co. Herzbergs two factor theory is concerned about the relationship between the employee satisfaction and motivation levels. Jan 24, 2011 compare and contrast maslows hierarchy of needs with herzbergs twofactor theory of motivation motivation is an intangible human asset which acts as a driver that pushes humans to be willing to perform certain actions. Using maslows hierarchy of needs and herzbergs motivationhygiene supposition, this company co.
Motivation is a well recognized concept in management and leadership practice of organisations. Theorys of motivation maslow, mcclelland, vroom, mayo. Maslows and herzbergs theory motivation selfimprovement. Maslow referred to the needs or motives, while herzberg dealt with goals or incentives which tend to satisfy those needs. Herzberg, a psychologist, proposed a theory about job factors that motivate employees. Oct 26, 2014 maslow vs herzberg theory of motivation difference between maslow and herzberg theory of motivation is that, maslows theory is concerned about different levels of needs which affect the motivation levels of the employees. Pdf comparing and contrasting abraham maslows hierarchy.
There is a great similarity between maslows and herzbergs models of motivation. Mostly this is because of the very serious lack of sound data in this area. As mentioned at the beginning, herzbergs theory states that motivation is divided into two dimensional e. The theory of motivation and motivation 1401 words 6 pages.
The key factor that differentiates twofactor theory is the idea of expectation. Herzberg s theory of motivation and maslow s hierarchy of needs. Analyze the application of maslows and herzbergs theories to an african or caribbean nation where more than a quarter of the population is unemployed. While herzbergs theory is an extension of maslows theory of motivation. Compare and contrast maslow s hierarchy of needs theory with. Maslow vs herzberg theory of motivation difference between maslow and herzberg theory of motivation is that, maslows theory is concerned about different levels of needs which affect the motivation levels of the employees. Similarities of maslow and herzberg theory of motivation.
A close examination of herzbergs model indicates that for those employees who have achieved a level of social and economic progress in the society, higherlevel needs of maslows model esteem and selfactualization are the primary motivators. According to herzberg, there are some job factors that result in satisfaction while there are other job factors that prevent dissatisfaction. Maslows theory of human motivation is based on the premise that a set of motivation systems, quite independent of rewards and unconscious desires, drives people. Herzberg theory is called two factors theory and maslows theory is called maslows demands mullins, 2010. Venugopalan maslows theory of motivation its relevance and application among nonmanagerial employees of selected public and private sector undertakings in kerala thesis.
Herzberg, a psychologist, proposed a theory about job. May 29, 2014 outline introduction maslows hierarchy of needs herzbergs two factor theory conclusion 3. Herzbergs theory is closely related to maslows need hierarchy. Maslow consequently extended the idea to include his observations of humans innate curiosity, over the years researches and authors has tend to criticizes the theory as being. Compare and contrast maslows hierarchy of needs with. A ghanaian perspective article pdf available january 2011 with 34,578 reads. Outline introduction maslows hierarchy of needs herzbergs two factor theory conclusion 3. Maslows hierarchy of needs is a theory in psychology anticipated by abraham maslow in his 1943 paper a theory of human motivation. High productivity is a long term benefits of employee motivation. Herzberg and maslows motivational theories asssignment. Application of frederick herzbergs twofactor theory in assessing and understanding employee motivation at work.
Motivation theories help managers to understand the best approaches to use to. Maslows need hierarchy theory of motivation its limitations. Equity theory motivation in the supermarket workplace. Ed421486 19970700 herzberg s theory of motivation and maslow s hierarchy of needs. The key factor that differentiates twofactor theory is the idea of. Abraham maslows research was actually focused on human personality, and he suggested that people differ because they differ in their needs and motivation. Motivationmaslows hierarchy of needs and herzberg two factor. The motivation theories of maslow hierarchy of needs, alderfer erg model and herzberg twofactor theory are closely related they can be linked and crossreferenced although each theory can challenge the others complete findings. Motivation in the workplace applying maslow and herzberg.
There could be a switch in focus from intrinsic to extrinsic motivation. Herzbergs twofactor theory of motivation human business. Comparison between maslow and herzbergs models are given below. This essay will then use these theories to explain how a team leader might use these to motivate their team members. Despite such similarities, there are some major differences between the two theories. Motivation among employees in organisations is a key managers function. Maslows theory intuitively appeals to practitioners and executives, though his theory is based on no formal research in management. The two factor theory has had a considerable amount of practical and as well as theoretical influences. Theory desi 1971 has suggested that is situations in which individuals are experiencing a high level of intrinsic motivation, the addition of extrinsic rewards for good performance may decrease intrinsic motivation. Maslows and herzbergs theory free download as powerpoint presentation. The main difference between maslow and herzberg s theory of motivation lies in the basis. Maslows theory is descriptive in nature while herzbergs theory is prescriptive in nature. In contrast, herzbergs theory on motivation reveals that there are a number of variables existing at the workplace that results in job satisfaction or dissatisfaction.
From a theoretical perspective, herzbergs motivation theory can be perceived as having similarities to maslows theory of need. While, maslow separated motivation into five different levels of needs. Theories of motivation maslow and herzberg by durga devi. Ed421486 19970700 herzbergs theory of motivation and maslows hierarchy of needs. Herzbergs theory of motivation and maslows hierarchy of needs. Descriptive or prescriptive v maslows theory or model is descriptive in nature. Difference between maslow and herzberg theory of motivation. May 15, 2017 one particular study especially focusing on the individuality of people, another critique for herzberg who only spoke about general human nature, found that different people satisfy different needs through their work. Maslows theory is a general theory on motivation which expresses that the urge to satisfy needs is the principle variable in motivation. Herzbergs twofactor theory of motivation applied to the.
Understanding how maslow, alderfer and herzberg are interrelated. Each of those theories at some point has been applied and tested as to its effects on. The main difference between maslow and herzbergs theory of motivation lies in the basis. They all illustrate what employees generally need and want in order to achieve a better work environment high morale and productivity. Herzbergs theory or model is prescriptive in nature. Criticism critics of herzbergs theory argue that the twofactor result is observed because it is natural for people to take credit for. To illustrate, hygiene or maintenance factors of herzberg are satisfied by the physiological, safety and belongingness needs of maslow, while motivation factors of herzberg tend. Herzbergs theory of motivation and maslows hierarchy of. Sep 19, 2018 the main difference between maslow and herzbergs theory of motivation lies in the basis. Employee needs and motivation boundless management. Maslows hierarchy of needs, a theory of psychology, helps understand and answer this question.
Compare and contrast maslow s hierarchy of needs theory. It is for this reason herzbergs theory is often considered, as an extension of maslows need hierarchy theory. A theory of human motivation get any book for free on. Due to this we can say that herzberg used maslows theory as the basis for his two factor theory and merely changed maslows hierarchy to suit his own beliefs and make the theory more applicable to a work environment. Sep 21, 2011 herzbergs theory is an extension of maslows theory of motivation. Herzberg theory of motivation herzbergs twofactor theory of motivation motivational theories and application to a highly creative and complex technology workforce behaviors of motivational theories herzbergs two factor theory vs job characteristics model motivation theories and sun 2 shade company maslows and herzbergs theories theories. The essay discusses about two motivational theories one is herzberg and another is maslow. Compare and contrast maslow s hierarchy of needs theory with herzberg s two factor theory. Maslows theory is the most popular and widely cited theory of motivation and has wide applicability. Herzberg s theory of motivation and maslow s hierarchy of needs joseph e gawel the catholic university of america among various behavioral theories long generally believed and embraced by american business are those of frederick herzberg and abraham maslow. Gawel, the catholic university of america among various behavioral theories long generally believed and embraced by american business are those of frederick herzberg and abraham maslow. It is mostly applicable to poor and developing countries where money is still a big motivating factor. On a comparison, one can see that the maintenance or hygiene factors are roughly equivalent to maslow s lower level needs and the motivators are roughly equivalent to maslow s higher level needs. Applications and criticisms avneet kaur jesus and mary college, university of delhi.
The hierarchy of needs theory by abraham maslow 1943, 1954 in the demanding world of business, motivation of the employers as well as of employees play a tremendous role mckay, importance of motivation and goal setting for businesses. Abraham maslows hierarchy of needs and fredrick herzbergs two factor theory. Accordingly, herzberg s twofactor theory posits that a good leader would give motivation to the members of staff in the organisation so that they would do their job well yusoff et al. Comparison of maslow and herzberg theory of motivation. Although maslow and herzbergs theories are both content theories and very similar, there are some differences.
Herzberg s twofactor theory of motivation applied to the motivational techniques within financial institutions abstract throughout time, many have attempted to develop detailed theories and studies of motivation, satisfaction, and selfawareness. I conceive this lack of sound facts to be due primarily to the absence of a valid theory of motivation. Herzbergs hygienemotivation theory is derived from the outcomes of several investigations into job satisfaction and job dissatisfaction, studies which replicated his original research in pittsburgh. Twofactor theory was formulated by frederick herzberg in 1959. Boone odv 420 march 15, 2015 maslows hierarchy of needs what motivates people. Jun 26, 20 content theories of motivation herzbergs motivation theory is one of the content theories of motivation. If maslows theory holds, there are some important implications for management. Herzberg named two basic factors, which are an employees source of satisfaction and motivation. Frederick herzberg s theory of motivation identifies two sets of factors that cause an employee to experience job satisfaction or dissatisfaction.
498 1535 1347 590 1191 1376 874 768 1323 1646 880 1004 136 588 401 978 678 1352 692 1482 980 496 859 207 137 603 1485 432 73 77 1246 82 1053 92 914 1259 1389 38 188 766 718 417 705 1228 499 591